One of the things I hate about mothering is that it seems to become a contest. Whose baby sleeps through the night first? Who has made the most sacrifices? Who is doing the best job?
In “natural” or “attached” parenting this attitude seems particularly blatant. Maybe I only feel that way because I don’t spend a lot of time with women who have other parenting styles, however, in AP land, judgments about parental fitness can fly fast. Thus, as a public service, I am letting everyone know that I am the most natural mother out there, so the rest of you can just stop arguing about who is worthy; none of you are compared to me. To wit:
- We conceived though a natural act of joyous, hot love on our 100% organic sheets.(1)
- I gave birth vaginally in the woods on a bed of moss attended only by woodland creatures who chanted affirmative birthing mantras. (2)
- I ate the placentas. (3)
- I exclusively breastfeed.(4)
- We cloth diaper, using homemade diapers woven from the wool of our flock of organic sheep. (5)
- We co-sleep, meaning the babies sleep in bed with us.(6)
- I have the babies in a sling all day long. In fact, we don’t even own one of those cruel devices, the stroller. (7)
- Because I always have the babies on me and respond to their needs instantly, they never, ever cry. (8)
- We don’t vaccinate.(9)
- We would never, ever do anything as barbaric as circumcision. In fact, we dress J. in t-shirts that read “Intact and Beautiful.”(10)
- We use elimination communication.(11)
- I make my own baby food from my organic garden.(12)
If I’ve missed any area of natural parenting let me know and I’ll tell you how I am better than you in that regard as well.
ETA: circumcision, EC, baby food.
Notes:- I have no comment on this.
- Sectioned in the hospital, actually.
- Ew.
- We still supplement about 4 ounces of formula per day. I think I should get 1 1/2 points anyway, however, because of the twin thing.
- Well, we do cloth diaper and I vastly prefer them. Every time I have to use disposables someone has an unpleasant blow out. However, we use a service. Can I still get a half point for the cloth diapering?
- Nope. The babies sleep in their own cribs in another room. Between B’s sleepwalking and my waking at every little snuffle even the bassinet in the bedroom was a bad idea.
- I love my stroller. I do baby-wear, but I can only do it for about 2 hours before my back gives out. Usually if a baby wants to be held I just sit with him or her on my lap.
- Can’t. Stop. Laughing.
- We do.
- We had planned on circumcision. I left the decision up to B. figuring that since he HAD a penis he probably had stronger views on this than I did and he voted to snip. However, J. came out with what the hospital pediatrician called a “partial natural circ.” and she told us that she didn’t have the expertise to circumcise him; if we wanted it done we would have to take him to a urologist which was way too much trouble. So…do I get a point for “natural through laziness”?
- To quote a commenter, EC is “Right Out” with twins. Sorry.
- The brief foray into solids we have taken thus far was indeed homemade baby food. I baked that sweet potato myself. I may also be able to lay claim to organics, as the potato was from Whole Foods, but I don’t remember for sure. My garden produces flowers, herbs and tomatos only, though, and nothing at all in December.
This entry was posted
on Tuesday, December 26th, 2006 at 5:08 am and is filed under From The Trenches.
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
Both comments and pings are currently closed.
December 26th, 2006 14:08
Oh, how I loved this post. I am in a (perhaps similar?) situation of having leftie friends who think they are being consistent with their leftie/environmental/peace beliefs by being strict, even evangelical APers. Even though Sears is a fundie who thinks men ought to “lead their households” (reference: his little-read book on “Christian Parenting), and the fact that their own beliefs are keeping them more chained to domestic life than our 1950’s foremothers probably ever were. When I had twins about your twins’ age, a friend sent me a link to an article about “ecological breastfeeding”. I guess breastfeeding twins wasn’t good enough; I was never supposed to use pumped milk, never supposed to put them down, and never supposed to feed them at a convenient time, even if it meant feeding one at a time all the time, around the clock. I was supposed to “surrender to being with my baby, giving up the cages in dark rooms and cages on wheels that are just intended to separate you from your baby”. The good thing was that the article was such a ridiculous thing to read as a twin mom that I was able to see the “more-natural-than-thou” philosopy for what it is, (which, IMHO, is one way of doing things that is not necessarily superior to all others) and let it go. Incidentally, I otherwise share those leftie/environmental/peace beliefs. I wrote about all of it here: http://allthis.typepad.com/allthis/2005/09/something_that_.html
The best blog post I ever read about this topic was written by the always eloquent Andrea here: http://www.athenadreaming.org/Beanie/archives/2005/07/in_which_i_reme.html
(Thanks for the free therapy, and your wonderful blog in general. I hope you don’t mind the friendly hijack. I admire the fact that you use humor so well, and continue to write about what matters to you even though you were pressured not to.)
December 26th, 2006 20:36
Tchah, woman. You forgot circumcision. Not only are you not allowed to whack the weenie of your baby boy, but you must put a “glad to be intact” shirt on your boys, and you must ask Mothers To Be about their plans.
(I left the decision up to the member of the family with a member and he voted yes cut ‘em for all three boys. Ugh. These days? It’s different but my baby is 9. . .)
Kate
December 26th, 2006 23:07
wow so well written.. i agree this is free therapy as i laughed so much and then cried cause its all true.. thanks for writing.. i too have twins.. boys just 7 months old.. you will for sure be added to my blog roll and again THANKS!
December 27th, 2006 10:01
The other commentors are right about free therapy — through reading this I realized that while I can lay claim to #4, I use it to feel less guilty about all the others (including circ’ing) . . . I think my problem is that I think there’s an aspect of truth to the stuff in the article Emmie mentioned — there are a billion ‘helpful’ ideas/products out there and it seems like it would be too easy to never touch one’s baby(ies) except to change diapers. The fact of the matter is that I do have a nagging little fear that I’m not doing enough, and I can’t determine if that little fear is functioning to urge me on, or tear me down. Probably the latter.
“We conceived though a natural act of joyous, hot love on our 100% organic sheets.”
I love that! Hysterical!
December 28th, 2006 16:22
This is one of the funniest things I’ve read all month, if not ever.
Well played!
December 29th, 2006 10:34
Oh, there’s a whole other issue that you forgot. Diaper-free, or Elimination Communication. You are supposed to “know” when you baby has to go and put a pot under his/her little butt. Even when you’re out, bring the potty with you. go to http://www.diaperfreebaby.org/ and read all about it. You’re not natural until you have a “potty-trained” 5 month old.
Loved your post, btw.
December 29th, 2006 17:36
Well, what AP philosphies do you subscribe to, then? There are lots of conventional parents out there and that is their choice but why, then criticize and make fun of more natural parenting methods while claiming to parent this way?? Your posts may be funny and sarcastic but they are really hypocritical.
ps: I’m also a twin mom by the way so I hope you won’t react in the “well, I have twins, so…” vein.
December 29th, 2006 17:42
Hee! I’ve got a friend whose baby is two weeks younger than my girls, and I’ve had very similar thoughts about the competitive aspect of AP, and the impossibility of same with twins. I’m convinced she secretly thinks she is a better mother than I am — the look of horror when I told her about moving the babies to the nursery was kind of a giveaway — but I’ve had to resign myself to just not caring. I exclusively BF and am taking baby steps with cloth diapers, but many of the rest of the AP tenets just don’t work so well when applied to twins. It’s a pure fact that someone will have to sometimes go unattended while the other nurses on demand, at least unless you are vastly more talented at tandem BF than I am or have a few more hands. (Elimination communication is Right Out.) I comfort myself that I’m farther along the attachment continuum than my mother was, and we did OK.
BTW, you forgot about making your own baby food with produce from your organic garden. I know you won’t want to do that until your children are ready for solids at approximately age four, but I’m sure you’re bearing it in mind for then :).
December 29th, 2006 19:33
Well, what AP philosphies do you subscribe to, then?
I breastfeed on demand, someting that took some considerable effort to make work. This often means I get very fragmented sleep because I get up multiple times a night. I cloth diaper. I respond to each and every cry no matter what I may be doing. “Cry it out” does not happen in my house.
I could go on. My point, however, wasn’t that the AP philosophy is bad, but that people end up wondering whether they “count” as “natural” parents if they couldn’t breastfeed, or had a c-section, or needed ART, or don’t co-sleep, or have a bad back and can’t baby-wear. You can always make the definition of what it takes to be a good mother more and more stringent.
Your posts may be funny and sarcastic but they are really hypocritical.
In what way are they hypocritical?
December 31st, 2006 11:19
Your babies are beautiful and you are hilarious. How you have managed to keep your sense of humor in your sleep deprived state is a mystery to me.
I’m thinking of starting my own movement (yet to be named) where you pay attention to yourself and your own darn kids instead of those around you and you just do whatever works for you and your child/children while supporting the diverse yet equally effective efforts of the mommies around you. So you get full points from me!
Mommies who are hellbent on comparisons and competition can bite it.
January 5th, 2007 15:38
Oh, thank you so much for this! This was really great.
March 9th, 2007 05:11
this was hysterical.. i loved it!!!
March 19th, 2007 11:31
Whew. You had me scared (and feeling more than a little incompetent).
May 15th, 2007 18:49
ROTFLMAO. Thanks.